Chair Pics ...

A lot of my friends do these month by month chair pics.  They're supposed to look like this ...

{That's my BF's little girl sweet P, also C's future wife.  She's now 19 months.  He likes older women.  He told me.}

But her dad is awesome at Photoshop and I ... well I don't even HAVE Photoshop SO I had to do my own version.  However I need your help.  I can't figure out which color option I like the best.  I played with the color on these pictures and I can't figure out if the first one makes my little guy look like he's jaundice or if they're artsy.  I definately like the color of the chair (this is his glider in his room bytheway, SOME day I'll post finished nursery pictures ...) and the wall better but let's be real here, all that matters is how the little man looks to a mommy.  SO which one?  Picture number 1 or 2?  I will stick with that color scheme for the next 12 months so give me y'all's input, my child's "chair pics" depend on it!